From hpklett at hotmail.com Sat Feb 14 01:30:51 2009 From: hpklett at hotmail.com (Hans-Peter Klett) Date: Sat Feb 14 01:31:00 2009 Subject: [rtmpy-dev] Project status Message-ID: Hello, I was just wondering a little about the status of this project, as i= t's a very appealing solution. I have been trying to work with red5, since= apparently even facebook uses it, but I hate the Java stack. I love pytho= n, and this project seems well written to boot. However, I'm a bit worried about the lack of apparent development/mailing l= ist activity. My main worry is that it will never make beta. Does there h= appen to be anyone out there that's devoted to making beta? Thanks - Hans-Peter Klett -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.collab.nl/pipermail/rtmpy-dev/attachments/20090213/0619dc= 26/attachment.htm From nick at boxdesign.co.uk Mon Feb 16 00:47:50 2009 From: nick at boxdesign.co.uk (Nick Joyce) Date: Mon Feb 16 00:48:08 2009 Subject: [rtmpy-dev] Project status In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: <9866B507-17A0-4560-899D-1A64D4C17DDA@boxdesign.co.uk> Hi Hans-Peter, Sorry for the lateness of the reply, just got back from the weekend. Let me introduce myself, I'm one of the devoted. :) This project has been in stasis for some time, for a combination of factors: 1) Lack of developers. Afaik I am the only Python developer working on this project. 2) Lack of time. I have been very busy with PyAMF (which RTMPy depends on heavily). Any free time I have had has gone into that project, in an attempt to make it as mature and as stable as I can. PyAMF has been very active for a long time is now at a point where most development can shift back to RTMPy. I have been quietly working on RTMPy since the new year and now have basic video streaming (although flakey) working. I haven't committed this to the repository yet (much to the dismay of various IRC users - you know who you are ;)) but will do when its a bit more stable etc. Adobe has recently announced that it will be opening up the specs to RTMP [1] which means that we can get a solid implementation written (much like PyAMF and the AMF specs). It remains to be seen how much they will open up - it would be amazing to have RTMFP in there, but somehow I doubt it (ever optimistic though!). Status update: Most of the basics for RTMP streaming is done (not very well tested mind you). The higher level functionality such as NetConnection, NetStream, Application etc. need to be written (which I currently in the middle of hacking out). I know that this project seems as if it is dead and that really p*sses me off .. but I am now starting to turn the rusty wheels of dev on this project. We could always use some help(!), especially if you know Python/ Twisted/RTMP .. Cheers, Nick [1] - http://www.adobe.com/aboutadobe/pressroom/pressreleases/200901/012009RTMP.html On 14 Feb 2009, at 00:30, Hans-Peter Klett wrote: > Hello, I was just wondering a little about the status of this > project, as it's a very appealing solution. I have been trying to > work with red5, since apparently even facebook uses it, but I hate > the Java stack. I love python, and this project seems well written > to boot. > > However, I'm a bit worried about the lack of apparent development/ > mailing list activity. My main worry is that it will never make > beta. Does there happen to be anyone out there that's devoted to > making beta? > > Thanks - Hans-Peter Klett > > _______________________________________________ > RTMPy mailing list - rtmpy-dev@rtmpy.org > http://lists.rtmpy.org/mailman/listinfo/rtmpy-dev From arnarbi at gmail.com Mon Feb 16 01:13:29 2009 From: arnarbi at gmail.com (Arnar Birgisson) Date: Mon Feb 16 01:13:39 2009 Subject: [rtmpy-dev] Project status In-Reply-To: <9866B507-17A0-4560-899D-1A64D4C17DDA@boxdesign.co.uk> References: <9866B507-17A0-4560-899D-1A64D4C17DDA@boxdesign.co.uk> Message-ID: <28012bc60902151613g56a548c2ja90d0e64a55d92ba@mail.gmail.com> Hi all, On Sun, Feb 15, 2009 at 23:47, Nick Joyce wrote: > I know that this project seems as if it is dead and that really p*sses me > off .. but I am now starting to turn the rusty wheels of dev on this > project. Don't beat yourself up, sounds like you've bee doing a lot of work. Maintaining open source takes *huge* effort, I'm just sorry I'm unable to contribute myself. cheers, Arnar From hpklett at hotmail.com Mon Feb 16 02:21:44 2009 From: hpklett at hotmail.com (Hans-Peter Klett) Date: Mon Feb 16 02:21:55 2009 Subject: [rtmpy-dev] Project status In-Reply-To: <9866B507-17A0-4560-899D-1A64D4C17DDA@boxdesign.co.uk> References: <9866B507-17A0-4560-899D-1A64D4C17DDA@boxdesign.co.uk> Message-ID: First of all, thanks for the great work you've put into this. I'm certainl= y aware of time issues; I've had to turn down two side projects in the last= couple of weeks. I have a bit of python experience, but twisted seems like quite the learnin= g curve. Event driven programming is great, but takes a good bit of knowle= dge regarding the development environment. If you've got any bugs (or "Wor= k Items" to borrow M$ parlance) in particular that are good starting points= for getting into this project, let me know. Thanks - Hans-Peter Klett > From: nick@boxdesign.co.uk > To: rtmpy-dev@rtmpy.org > Date: Sun, 15 Feb 2009 23:47:50 +0000 > Subject: Re: [rtmpy-dev] Project status > = > Hi Hans-Peter, > = > Sorry for the lateness of the reply, just got back from the weekend. > = > Let me introduce myself, I'm one of the devoted. :) > = > This project has been in stasis for some time, for a combination of = > factors: > = > 1) Lack of developers. Afaik I am the only Python developer working on = > this project. > 2) Lack of time. I have been very busy with PyAMF (which RTMPy depends = > on heavily). Any free time I have had has gone into that project, in = > an attempt to make it as mature and as stable as I can. PyAMF has been = > very active for a long time is now at a point where most development = > can shift back to RTMPy. > = > I have been quietly working on RTMPy since the new year and now have = > basic video streaming (although flakey) working. I haven't committed = > this to the repository yet (much to the dismay of various IRC users - = > you know who you are ;)) but will do when its a bit more stable etc. > = > Adobe has recently announced that it will be opening up the specs to = > RTMP [1] which means that we can get a solid implementation written = > (much like PyAMF and the AMF specs). It remains to be seen how much = > they will open up - it would be amazing to have RTMFP in there, but = > somehow I doubt it (ever optimistic though!). > = > Status update: > = > Most of the basics for RTMP streaming is done (not very well tested = > mind you). The higher level functionality such as NetConnection, = > NetStream, Application etc. need to be written (which I currently in = > the middle of hacking out). > = > I know that this project seems as if it is dead and that really p*sses = > me off .. but I am now starting to turn the rusty wheels of dev on = > this project. > = > We could always use some help(!), especially if you know Python/ = > Twisted/RTMP .. > = > Cheers, > = > Nick > = > [1] - http://www.adobe.com/aboutadobe/pressroom/pressreleases/200901/0120= 09RTMP.html > = > On 14 Feb 2009, at 00:30, Hans-Peter Klett wrote: > = > > Hello, I was just wondering a little about the status of this = > > project, as it's a very appealing solution. I have been trying to = > > work with red5, since apparently even facebook uses it, but I hate = > > the Java stack. I love python, and this project seems well written = > > to boot. > > > > However, I'm a bit worried about the lack of apparent development/ = > > mailing list activity. My main worry is that it will never make = > > beta. Does there happen to be anyone out there that's devoted to = > > making beta? > > > > Thanks - Hans-Peter Klett > > > > _______________________________________________ > > RTMPy mailing list - rtmpy-dev@rtmpy.org > > http://lists.rtmpy.org/mailman/listinfo/rtmpy-dev > = > _______________________________________________ > RTMPy mailing list - rtmpy-dev@rtmpy.org > http://lists.rtmpy.org/mailman/listinfo/rtmpy-dev -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.collab.nl/pipermail/rtmpy-dev/attachments/20090215/f696bf= 56/attachment.htm